Voters in multiple Democratic-leaning states approved ballot measures restricting transgender participation in sports and medical interventions for minors during last week's midterm elections, according to a report published by the Manhattan Institute. Despite strong Democratic performance overall, Arizona, Colorado, and Washington residents voted to ban biological males from competing on girls' and women's sports teams, while Nebraska passed a constitutional amendment making sports participation dependent on biological sex. Colorado also approved Proposition 135, which prohibits surgical procedures for trans-identified minors, with 52% support.
The Colorado surgical ban faced opposition from the state's Medical Society, the Colorado chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Colorado Academy of Family Physicians, the Colorado Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Society, and the Colorado Psychiatric Society, the report notes. However, the measure matches the American Society of Plastic Surgeons' stance against surgical interventions for minors, which points to weak evidence and an unfavorable risk-benefit balance. At the federal level, the U.S. Department of Education launched investigations into Albuquerque Public Schools, Santa Fe Public Schools in New Mexico, and Pennsylvania's Pennsbury School District over social transition policies that may violate parental rights. The department is working with the Justice Department on enforcement actions against another Pennsylvania district for policies that let staff facilitate social transitions without informing parents, potentially breaking federal privacy laws.
The Department of Health and Human Services issued a final rule stating that gender dysphoria doesn't qualify as a disability under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, clearing up confusion from a 2024 Biden-era rule. HHS Office for Civil Rights Director Paula M. Stannard said the rule "ensures recipients of HHS funding follow those definitions, eliminating confusion for the people they serve and restoring confidence in the statute." At a recent Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine conference, Dr. Laura Edwards-Leeper, a former psychologist at Boston Children's Hospital's gender clinic who brought the Dutch Protocol to the U.S. in 2007, criticized the current affirmative care model. She stated that medical organizations have shifted to an "affirm-without-question" approach that creates major problems and that departing from established standards raises serious ethical concerns.
The ballot results may intensify divisions within the Democratic Party, with progressives wanting to fight the restrictions while moderates prefer focusing on economic issues, Politico observes in coverage cited by the report. A UK psychiatrist writing in the Independent warned that proposed "conversion therapy" laws criminalizing attempts to change someone's sexual orientation or gender identity could prevent adequate mental health care for sex-distressed youth. Dr. Az Hakeem argued that conflating sexual orientation with gender identity will create a chilling effect that stops counselors from working with this population due to fear of criminal penalties, noting that clinicians don't simply affirm everything patients say in other contexts. While Edwards-Leeper opposes complete bans on gender medicine for minors, she maintains the affirmative model currently lacks proper screening safeguards and risks harming young people who might otherwise grow up same-sex attracted. The voting patterns suggest public opinion on transgender policies may diverge significantly from Democratic Party positions, even in solidly blue states.

